On Point blog, page 19 of 25

State v. Michael D. Sporle, 2009AP2737-CR, District IV, 4/29/10

court of appeals decision (1-judge, not for publication); for Sporle: Robert J. Jackson; BiC; Resp.; Reply

Implied Consent Procedure, § 343.305(2)

¶12 The officer complied with her obligations to provide the “Informing the Accused” information and to make an alternative test available. The officer informed Sporle that, if he took the requested test, he could have an alternative test free of charge,

Read full article >

State v. Kyle J. Graske, 2009AP1933-CR, District II, 3/24/2010

court of appeals decision (1-judge; not for publication); BiC; Resp. Br.; Reply Br.

Miranda – Suppressed Statement and Probable Cause

¶7        First, we will address the State’s argument that Kohel’s statement “[w]e just smoked an hour ago” was voluntary and should not be suppressed. The trial court found, and we agree, that Kohel’s statement was the result of a custodial interrogation and should be suppressed.

Read full article >

State v. Stephen A. Broad, 2009AP1983-CR, District II, 3/17/2010

court of appeals decision (1-judge, not for publication) BiC; Resp. Br.; Reply Br.

Traffic Arrest
Probable cause to believe Broad drove on public roadway, hence to arrest for OWI, where car was found off the road, Broad was in driver’s seat and admitted to being driver, car “was warm and running.”

Right to Testify
Violation of rule requiring contemporaneous colloquy as to waiver of right to testify at trial doesn’t lead to automatic reversal of conviction;

Read full article >

State v. Bradley A. Krahn, 2009AP2406-CR, Dist II 2/3/10

court of appeals decision (not for publication); BiCResp BrReply

Transport in Squad Didn’t Convert Stop to Arrest
Temporary detention for OWI not converted to arrest by transport, in squad while handcuffed, to police station where field sobriety tests could be performed safely; court notes that officer expressly told Krahn detention was temporary and that handcuffs and transport were for safety,

Read full article >

State v. Deon Bernard Howell, 2008AP3116-CR, Dist I, 1/26/10

court of appeals decision (not recommended for publication)

Probable Cause to Arrest
Probable cause to arrest Howell, where he showed up at drug house after police were executing search warrant and had found photo of him throwing gang signs plus he matched description of drug dealer in warrant application.

Read full article >

Fond du Lac Co. v. Jennifer E. Bailey, 2009AP 1789-FT, Dist II, 1/20/10

court of appeals decision (1-judge; ineligible for publication)

Traffic Stop – Crossing Center Line
Probable cause to stop for crossing center line, even if momentary and even if driving otherwise flawless.

Read full article >

State v. Bradley J. Tadych, 2009AP1911-CR, Dist II, 1/20/10

court of appeals decision (1-judge; ineligible for publication)

OWI – Probable Cause for PBT
Probable cause to administer PBT: rollover accident, odor of intoxicant, Tadych acknowledged drinking; also, PBT result admissible to establish probable cause to arrest.

Read full article >

State v. Stanley W. Puchacz, 2010 WI App 30

court of appeals decision; for Puchacz: William M. Hayes
Resp Br

OWI Enhancer, § 346.65(2) – Out-of-State Conviction
Michigan convictions for driving while visibly impaired may be counted as Wisconsin OWI priors, given “broad interpretation and application of the final phrase in Wis. Stat. § 343.307(1)(d) and the public policy supporting our drunk driving laws,” ¶¶12-13.

Traffic Stop – Deviating from Center Line, § 346.05
Crossing center line,

Read full article >

State v. Hezekiah Laster, Jr., 2009AP692-CR, Dist III, 1/12/10

court of appeals decision (not recommended for publication)

Arrest – Probable Cause
Arrest based on probable cause where drug informant identified photo of Laster as person he just bought drugs from.

Read full article >

Arrest – Probable Cause – Specific Examples: Traffic Violation – Deviating from Center Line, § 346.05

State v. Michael L. Popke, 2009 WI 37, reversing unpublished opinion
For Popke: John Miller Carroll, Aaron W. Schenk

Issue/Holding: Police had probable cause to believe Popke violated § 346.05, driving on right-side of highway:

¶16      In this case, the officer testified that he was sitting at a stop sign when the defendant turned left onto the road directly ahead of where the officer was sitting.

Read full article >